|
|
Post by arlieimperfection on May 28, 2020 2:04:47 GMT -6
Does anyone know about this version? It's kinda similar to Mystery version but sounds different, especialy "if you have to leave" line. youtu.be/z8GUFFRFS8USeems pretty identical to the Fallen version but the strings are soooo loud. |
|
|
|
Post by imnotbroken118 on Oct 3, 2021 21:36:27 GMT -6
Every time I listen to the Fallen or Origin version of this song I find myself loving David's backup vocals. I know they re-recorded the band version during the Fallen sessions with the intent to put it on the album but Wind-up decided to use the demo instead. I wonder if David was fired before they re-recorded it or if they made an intentional decision to record only Amy's vocals for backup. They keys sound more David-style than Amy so I guess I assume he was still around for the recording. I feel like there's so much mystery to David's story with the band. I listened to an in depth interview from him once and it filled in a lot of gaps but not everything. I'm surprised neither Amy or Ben ever really talked about him or his departure.
Also, I am just realizing that there is acoustic guitar in the same version(s) starting in the instrumental after the bridge. It's super drowned out in the strings on Fallen but you can still hear it. It's much more prominent on Origin. How have I heard this song a million times and never picked up on that?
|
|
dekrou
Baron/Baroness of EvThreads
Posts: 13
|
Post by dekrou on Oct 5, 2021 0:16:10 GMT -6
Every time I listen to the Fallen or Origin version of this song I find myself loving David's backup vocals. I know they re-recorded the band version during the Fallen sessions with the intent to put it on the album but Wind-up decided to use the demo instead. I wonder if David was fired before they re-recorded it or if they made an intentional decision to record only Amy's vocals for backup. But David's vocals are literally like 3 seconds long and yes, he recorded Keys in both Origin and band versions. |
|
|
|
Post by imnotbroken118 on Oct 6, 2021 17:18:37 GMT -6
Every time I listen to the Fallen or Origin version of this song I find myself loving David's backup vocals. I know they re-recorded the band version during the Fallen sessions with the intent to put it on the album but Wind-up decided to use the demo instead. I wonder if David was fired before they re-recorded it or if they made an intentional decision to record only Amy's vocals for backup. But David's vocals are literally like 3 seconds long and yes, he recorded Keys in both Origin and band versions. There are many 3-second moments in Ev songs that I love. It's the attention to the little details that makes their music so special.  |
|
Thomas
Viscount/Viscountess of EvThreads
I was an eagle in flight...
Posts: 697 
|
Post by Thomas on Oct 14, 2021 18:47:35 GMT -6
Every time I listen to the Fallen or Origin version of this song I find myself loving David's backup vocals. I know they re-recorded the band version during the Fallen sessions with the intent to put it on the album but Wind-up decided to use the demo instead. I wonder if David was fired before they re-recorded it or if they made an intentional decision to record only Amy's vocals for backup. They keys sound more David-style than Amy so I guess I assume he was still around for the recording. I feel like there's so much mystery to David's story with the band. I listened to an in depth interview from him once and it filled in a lot of gaps but not everything. I'm surprised neither Amy or Ben ever really talked about him or his departure. Also, I am just realizing that there is acoustic guitar in the same version(s) starting in the instrumental after the bridge. It's super drowned out in the strings on Fallen but you can still hear it. It's much more prominent on Origin. How have I heard this song a million times and never picked up on that? Yes, David was still around when they recorded Fallen, and he tracked piano and arranged some strings (according to the booklet, and Amy said she didn't play piano on Fallen, but wrote the notes), but he was fired after recordings were finished. Amy and Ben had a meeting with their label, and the label told them to fire David. This is what I remember from David's interview. |
|
